I haven't been a part of that conversation, but I can see how BRB's question could be interpreted as asking why the tagged individuals are the ones who hate America? Even though he was asking them why the protesters hated America, the wording of the question was not exactly clear. Archy was already under fire for his viewpoints so his response made sense.
That is how it looked to me, even though I think Archy has some pretty backward views, and I also respect and admire BRB as much as anyone else on this board.
(NDJ on the other hand is definitely an anti-American piece of $h!t)