More insinuations.... Sarcasm is fine, but your comment was one that would be made by a 16 year old girl, with a C average. It was telling, because you were obviously offended by me questioning of your own assertions (hypocrisy). I'm not going to continue to argue with you over signs of intelligence, or lack there of. Neither you, or that discussion is worth my time. Now, on with the conversation. You're going to penalize a coach for having the ability to bring in superior talent? There isn't a top flight coach out there that doesn't have that ability. Now, does Saban manage to accumulate better talent than most everyone else? Sure he does, but in my opinion that is part of being considered an excellent coach in the college game. I understand what you're saying. Is he the best X's and O's guy? Probably not, but when I turn on an Alabama game I see a well-disciplined team, who is confident, aware, and just damn good....
Personally, I don't think he is the greatest coach ever, but he deserves to be included in the conversation based off of his accomplishments alone....
I think you and I differ on what characteristics make up a "great" coach....
I'm not offended at all. In fact I enjoy a little verbal sparring. (but to be clear, you were the one who felt compelled on the basis of one question to situate someone else on the intellect scale..........16 year old girl c student?).
And, any cursory reading of this board offers multiple examples of insinuations, sarcasms, etc. I guess I was under the impression the purpose of the board was to opine and question and dialogue.
In any case, I actually agree with your last two statements about not being the greatest coach (yet); but should be in the conversation at some point. We probably don't disagree much on the characteristics making up a great coach. I just tend to leaven my opinion with the fact that he has had tremendous talent to work with.
Enjoy the day.........
I think we might differ than, on whether that amount of talent should at all tarnish, or alter his perception/standing as a great coach....
Enjoy your day as well....