.... on defense. There was not much for offensive talent on the 08 team.
Joe Ganz
Roy Helu
Marlon Lucky
Quentin Castille
Meno Holt
Nate Swift
Todd Peterson
Mike McNeill
RB is the only spot that has noticeably more talent. Ganz may have a slight edge over TA in terms of talent but not by a lot. I love the Swift-Peterson-McNeill trio but there is no way they are more talented than Westerkamp-DPE-Carter.
The offenses are nearly identical. A little bit here, a little bit there, the only difference. Basically a tossup.
Should we compare defenses? Because that's where the HUGE difference is, and it's not even close. Hence the odd votes for 2015, because that 2008 team would demolish this team.
It's hard to tell how much talent there is on defense when they are constantly put it terrible positions.