Perhaps it is based on how they did in the game against WVU. We could speculate for days, or someone could RTFA:
By John Antonik for MSNsportsNET.com
July 2, 2007
ESPN.com’s Ivan Maisel recently offered us his version of college football’s 100 iconic moments, rolling out 138 years worth of history in five days. Recruits are ranked. The History Channel has the show The Most.
If they can come up with lists, why can’t we?
Over the next three weeks we will reveal the 50 greatest college football players, the 20 greatest coaches and the 25 best teams West Virginia has faced on the gridiron.
Of course many of the choices are obvious. Pitt’s Tony Dorsett abused the Mountaineers for four years. Same goes for Larry Csonka. Joe Paterno, Jock Sutherland, Tom Osborne and Bobby Bowden rank among the greatest coaches in NCAA history. Miami, Pitt, Nebraska, Syracuse and Penn State all won national championships during years it faced West Virginia.
However, some of our picks weren’t quite so obvious.
Our criteria were simple: the players, coaches and teams had to not only achieve fame but also perform well against West Virginia. That eliminates many great players like Franco Harris, John Mackey, Michael Irvin and Barry Sanders who had exceptional playing careers but had ordinary games against West Virginia.
Is this a definitive list of the very best players, coaches and teams West Virginia has faced? Probably not. We’re sure you’ll come up with many more. So without further delay, let the arguing begin!