I'd take Taylor over Shoelace or Braxton Miller.
I just find it odd that you ask if he is as good at the other B1G QB's, but then gone on to say that he is a good a Bridgewater or Mariotta. Bridgewater is a different type of QB, but I would take Mariotta in two seconds.
That being said, as long as Taylor keeps the 'happy feet' away, I'm more than happy with him.