this is a post i put together in another thread, but it seems applicable here:
i don't want to trash our guys, but i would say the following players left by the previous staff are what i would consider "quality":
murtha
slauson
mike smith
hickman
williams
jaivario
the following still have potential to be quality:
caputo (walk-on)
marcel
the rest are just guys:
dj jones
mike huff
andy christensen
barrett
so, they left us with 6 quality linemen. SIX! it's our bad luck that of those 6, two were seniors and the rest have struggled with injuries this year (with jaivario being obviously the biggest blow).
the 2007 recruiting class netted us exactly TWO linemen total: jaivario (stud) and marcel, a project that still needs more time in the weight room.
the 2006 class had the following:
nicks
cruz barrett
victory haines
ricky henry (didn't qualify, resigned in 2008)
hickman
williams
dj jones
mike smith (recruited as a defensive end)
giving us a juco that was pretty good for one season (nicks) and THREE quality high school linemen in smith, hickman and williams - a good class. from what i can tell, callahan's ONLY good class of OL.
the 2005 class had the following:
pasteur
picou
picou
roark
giving us exactly ZERO quality linemen.
not exactly an impressive record of success in leaving us a "stacked" offensive line. yes, they appeared to have some good ones lined up for the 2008 class, but who's to say they would have stuck anyways, given the sinking ship that was cally's last season.
This. Maybe Barney isnt the guy. Maybe he is. We really dont know yet because again our line wasnt deep this year and we had injuries.
IF from that 2008 class we would have gotten Hoch, Givens, and Robinson we would be in pretty good shape. Hoch starts at MU; Givens at CU; Robinson at ND.