I guess the only reason I would like to see Martinez start is because I'm tired of seeing a new starter at QB every year. He showed what he can be at Manhattan and Stillwater. A lot of college QB's go their whole careers without having games like that, Taylor did it as a frosh. Did he have setbacks? Absolutely. But I'm not convinced Carnes is immune to those freshmen growing pains. He'll absolutely have setbacks if he starts as a freshmen, I'll put money on it. If he is good enough to take the job away from Taylor, then holy cow we're in good shape at QB. We'll have the best backup in the country. I'll leave it to the coaches to decide who gives us the best chance to win. I don't know nearly enough about Carnes to know he gives us the best shot, neither do any of you. I'll 100% support whoever they trot out there.