2011 Taylor would be lower, and 2012 would probably be the same as Tommy. Interesting. I'm of the belief that a healthy freshman or junior TMart would have us in a better position than we're in now but that's just me. He's a better runner and he's had better accuracy ratings than Tommy through their first 2 years. JmoIt's not just you. There are a lot of insane people out there who horribly misremember Martinez's time here. He made 10% more of his throws and had a take it to the house ability that Armstrong lacks. I would feel much, much more confident if it was him, regardless of which "year" of him it is.
That being said I don't think Armstrong is terrible and I have hope he can improve.