NCAA 12 vs. Madden 12

[Danny Bateman]

Which one are you guys looking forward to more?

 

I'd obviously venture to guess NCAA, as most of you are raring to go with DONU, and I myself usually enjoy NCAA more, but honestly from a totally objective standpoint, it sounds like all the upgrades to Franchise and Superstar in Madden outweigh the coaching carousel and addition of dreads in NCAA

 

But it's all a matter of opinion.

[Landlord]

Madden will be a far superior product this year, which is really a shame, because the NCAA series (naturally) is more appealing to me. I wish 2K could still make football games :'( we'd be seeing some revolutionary products.

[jsneb83]

Yeah I think Madden will be the better game, but I am looking forward to NCAA to see Nebraska in the B1G.

[Enhance]

Madden games have the same problem every year that is impossible to fix - it's just not as interesting as college football to me. If there were ever a day dominated by college and nfl games, I'd watch the college games instead. If I had to choose between the NFL or college football going away forever, I'd choose the NFL.

 

That said, I'll probably get both and return the one I don't like.

[It'sNotAFakeID]

I'm with Enhance on this-college football is WAY more exciting than NFL and because EA can't forcibly make me choose to like the NFL more, I'm going to continue to consider NCAA a better game than Madden. The only way I'll play Madden is if I get the game for free

[Enhance]

I'm with Enhance on this-college football is WAY more exciting than NFL and because EA can't forcibly make me choose to like the NFL more, I'm going to continue to consider NCAA a better game than Madden. The only way I'll play Madden is if I get the game for free

Agree with bolded part.