Except you don't have clue one as to whether or not Carnes sucks. Which is why the logic of your Martinez bashing essays falls flat time and time and time again.
Question: How good would Carnes have to be in order to be better for us than Martinez post-Mizzou?
Answer: Not very.
Do you get it now, Dude?
You all seem to believe Martinez will magically be better once his ankle heals. I say:
1) That is as shaky an assumption as the assumption that Carnes will be good; AND
2) There is ample reason to believe that his ankle problem ain't exactly in the rearview.
My goodness, Hujan. I can hardly believe you wrote that. The difference was night and day after his injuries (ankle and turf toe). I would think even the most casual NU fan could see that.
To state he won't be any better if/when he gets healthy is just crazy.
Im not sure about you but i read it as being geared more towards the possibility of Martinez never fully recovering.