Would you transfer if you were Silas Redd?

[NUance]

All eyes are on Silas Redd. I think he'll stay at Penn State. And I think that's probably the best decision for him. LINK

[Minnesota_husker]

Yes- Simple fact is this: Redd will not get the talent around him to succeed and be at his best. He has to think about his future. Recruits wont come in and he needs a good O-line and chance to showcase his skills.

 

I understand the idea of being Loyal to PSU, but remember they weren't loyal to him. They weren't loyal to any of their players by what they did and put them in jeopardy. Redd didnt cover this stuff up but he will pay for it...

 

That is like saying all the people in the theater in Aurora deserve punishment for being there when Holmes killed a bunch of people.. they had no say or control in what he did.

[GSG]

I would probably leave. If I stayed in-conference, I'd make sure it's a school that doesn't play Penn State for the rest of my career. I'd most likely go out of the conference.

[GM_Tood]

I'd be gone.

[huKSer]

I'm pretty sure all the seniors will probably stay. Most of juniors. Current recruits and freshmen will be the most raided.

[Minnesota_husker]

I'm pretty sure all the seniors will probably stay. Most of juniors. Current recruits and freshmen will be the most raided.

He has 2 years of eligibility left... He is gone-zo

[VectorVictor]

I'm pretty sure all the seniors will probably stay. Most of juniors. Current recruits and freshmen will be the most raided.

He has 2 years of eligibility left... He is gone-zo

 

nm

[WoodyHayes1951]

I think he stays.

 

He is NFL bound after this year anyway

[NUance]

I think he stays.

 

He is NFL bound after this year anyway

My thoughts exactly. And he'll be viewed as being loyal for sticking with PSU, even if just for one year.

[hskerholic]

If I was him I would go to Iowa they have zero depth and they like to run the ball!

 

(null)

[Excel]

If I played at Penn State I'd stay. Can't quite pin why though...

[NUance]

Five Penn State players teams are targeting

By Dave Carey | CBSSports.com; July 24, 2012 11:11 am ET

 

Silas Redd, RB, junior: He ran for 1,241 yards and seven touchdowns last year for one of the worst passing teams in the country. Redd would be the starter on nearly every team in the country. He already has been linked to USC , while other reports having him staying in State College for one more year before going pro.

Eugene Lewis, WR, freshman: The first-year player was the crown jewel of coach Bill O'Brien's first recruiting class. If he stays at Penn State he will never play in a bowl game. If he transfers, he has the talent to play immediately and could be with another program for four seasons.

Jordan Hill, DT, senior: He would basically be a rental this season, but Hill is regarded as one of the top players at his position in the Big Ten and is an anchor on most defensive lines. Hill had 59 tackles, 3.5 sacks and three fumble recoveries last season.

Khairi Fortt, LB, junior: The former four-star recruit played in every game last season as he recorded 33 tackles and 2.5 sacks. He has bulked-up during his career and was expected to be a key part of the defense. Fortt's body now matches his elite talent, making him an immediate impact player who also can contribute on special teams.

Bill Belton, RB, sophomore: Despite a 5-foot-10, 196-pound frame, the former four-star recruit may be the most dynamic offensive player at Penn State. Belton, who acted as a wildcat quarterback last year, transitioned to running back this season and was expected to be a major contributor. He had scholarship offers from schools such as Florida and Oregon.

LINK

Article at www.cbssports.com. The sharks smell blood in the water and are closing in. From this it sounds like the frosh WR Lewis has the most to gain by leaving. This article almost makes me feel sorry for Penn State. Almost.