JJkinz Posted September 1, 2016 Share Posted September 1, 2016 I really expect only 10 on the field and to take the DOG penalty. I don't care what the game situation is, that is what should happen. Personally, I would like to see our ten players line up facing backwards on one knee. If Fresno has some class they will decline the penalty but, if they don't decline it, that is fine too. What would actually happen if Fresno declines the DOG penalty? Would we line up again to punt it again? It's a little confusing to me because I think of all the times teams take a DOG penalty on purpose to give their punter more room to work with - couldn't the opposing coach just decline that penalty again and again? NU wouldn't keep taking the DOG penalty over and over again. They do it once as a gesture, and the Fresno State coaches may decline it, understanding the situation. Riley and the Fresno coach may even discuss it before the game. Right - I guess what I'm asking is, if we took the DOG penalty and DeRuyter declines, would the protocol be for us to line up to punt again from the same yard line? Quote Link to comment
84HuskerLaw Posted September 1, 2016 Share Posted September 1, 2016 I really expect only 10 on the field and to take the DOG penalty. I don't care what the game situation is, that is what should happen. Personally, I would like to see our ten players line up facing backwards on one knee. If Fresno has some class they will decline the penalty but, if they don't decline it, that is fine too. What would actually happen if Fresno declines the DOG penalty? Would we line up again to punt it again? It's a little confusing to me because I think of all the times teams take a DOG penalty on purpose to give their punter more room to work with - couldn't the opposing coach just decline that penalty again and again? I think two delay of game penalties in a row - the second should include 'loss of down' and therefore the opponent takes over on downs. Quote Link to comment
commando Posted September 1, 2016 Share Posted September 1, 2016 business as usual....then after a nice punt they show sam on the big screen giving a thumbs up or some other gesture they have of him on film. Quote Link to comment
Landlord Posted September 1, 2016 Share Posted September 1, 2016 Is DOG even a penalty that is allowed to be accepted/declined? Quote Link to comment
ColoradoHusk Posted September 1, 2016 Share Posted September 1, 2016 I really expect only 10 on the field and to take the DOG penalty. I don't care what the game situation is, that is what should happen. Personally, I would like to see our ten players line up facing backwards on one knee. If Fresno has some class they will decline the penalty but, if they don't decline it, that is fine too. What would actually happen if Fresno declines the DOG penalty? Would we line up again to punt it again? It's a little confusing to me because I think of all the times teams take a DOG penalty on purpose to give their punter more room to work with - couldn't the opposing coach just decline that penalty again and again? NU wouldn't keep taking the DOG penalty over and over again. They do it once as a gesture, and the Fresno State coaches may decline it, understanding the situation. Riley and the Fresno coach may even discuss it before the game. Right - I guess what I'm asking is, if we took the DOG penalty and DeRuyter declines, would the protocol be for us to line up to punt again from the same yard line? Yes, NU would just punt from the original line of scrimmage, since the penalty was declined. I think you are making this too complicated. Quote Link to comment
ColoradoHusk Posted September 1, 2016 Share Posted September 1, 2016 Is DOG even a penalty that is allowed to be accepted/declined? I have seen it where it has been declined, and I have seen it where commentators/officials say it can't be declined. Quote Link to comment
ColoradoHusk Posted September 1, 2016 Share Posted September 1, 2016 business as usual....then after a nice punt they show sam on the big screen giving a thumbs up or some other gesture they have of him on film. That would be really cool. Husker Vision could show something like "Sam says 'Nice Punt!!!'" or something corny like that. Quote Link to comment
JJ Husker Posted September 2, 2016 Share Posted September 2, 2016 I don't know why but even the thought of this is making me tear up. Can't imagine the emotions his coaches and teammates will be experiencing. Quote Link to comment
JJkinz Posted September 2, 2016 Share Posted September 2, 2016 I really expect only 10 on the field and to take the DOG penalty. I don't care what the game situation is, that is what should happen. Personally, I would like to see our ten players line up facing backwards on one knee. If Fresno has some class they will decline the penalty but, if they don't decline it, that is fine too. What would actually happen if Fresno declines the DOG penalty? Would we line up again to punt it again? It's a little confusing to me because I think of all the times teams take a DOG penalty on purpose to give their punter more room to work with - couldn't the opposing coach just decline that penalty again and again? NU wouldn't keep taking the DOG penalty over and over again. They do it once as a gesture, and the Fresno State coaches may decline it, understanding the situation. Riley and the Fresno coach may even discuss it before the game. Right - I guess what I'm asking is, if we took the DOG penalty and DeRuyter declines, would the protocol be for us to line up to punt again from the same yard line? Yes, NU would just punt from the original line of scrimmage, since the penalty was declined. I think you are making this too complicated. So change games to Ohio State. We're at the 40 and want to take a delay of game penalty to give our punter a little more room to work with. Meyer declines the penalty. So according to you, we line up and punt from the original line of scrimmage again. Yet, we still want to have some more breathing room, so we take a second delay of game penalty. Meyer declines again. So we line up to punt again.... Obviously the above scenario doesn't make much sense, but since it is such as simple concept for you can you please enlighten me on how the above scenario would play out? The longest CFB of all time? Quote Link to comment
Mavric Posted September 2, 2016 Author Share Posted September 2, 2016 I really expect only 10 on the field and to take the DOG penalty. I don't care what the game situation is, that is what should happen. Personally, I would like to see our ten players line up facing backwards on one knee. If Fresno has some class they will decline the penalty but, if they don't decline it, that is fine too. What would actually happen if Fresno declines the DOG penalty? Would we line up again to punt it again? It's a little confusing to me because I think of all the times teams take a DOG penalty on purpose to give their punter more room to work with - couldn't the opposing coach just decline that penalty again and again? NU wouldn't keep taking the DOG penalty over and over again. They do it once as a gesture, and the Fresno State coaches may decline it, understanding the situation. Riley and the Fresno coach may even discuss it before the game. Right - I guess what I'm asking is, if we took the DOG penalty and DeRuyter declines, would the protocol be for us to line up to punt again from the same yard line? Yes, NU would just punt from the original line of scrimmage, since the penalty was declined. I think you are making this too complicated. So change games to Ohio State. We're at the 40 and want to take a delay of game penalty to give our punter a little more room to work with. Meyer declines the penalty. So according to you, we line up and punt from the original line of scrimmage again. Yet, we still want to have some more breathing room, so we take a second delay of game penalty. Meyer declines again. So we line up to punt again.... Obviously the above scenario doesn't make much sense, but since it is such as simple concept for you can you please enlighten me on how the above scenario would play out? The longest CFB of all time? I couldn't find anything specifically covering this. But I believe it would fall under the Referee's discretion. He could instruct the punting team to snap the ball and, if they still didn't, could enforce other penalties (unsporting foul, etc.). Quote Link to comment
JJ Husker Posted September 2, 2016 Share Posted September 2, 2016 I think Mav is right. After 2nd time the offensive team would likely be warned to snap the ball or be faced with forfeiting the game. I've seen DOG declined before and it seems the team always snapped it the next time. What is curious though are all the times a team does it to give their kicker more room and it often gets accepted. Pretty sure this won't be a thing this Saturday... Quote Link to comment
Mavric Posted September 3, 2016 Author Share Posted September 3, 2016 Not sure he was supposed to tweet this out but... Quote Link to comment
84HuskerLaw Posted September 3, 2016 Share Posted September 3, 2016 doubtful this one will happen now as it has been published. too risky to do it when the opponent can plan accordingly. 1 Quote Link to comment
Bigred_inSD Posted September 3, 2016 Share Posted September 3, 2016 doubtful this one will happen now as it has been published. too risky to do it when the opponent can plan accordingly. What? Huh? We aren't going to punt, Fresno will understand the reason, they aren't going to call a timeout and ruin it. Or allow us to score every play so we don't punt. Quote Link to comment
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.