You didn't read very well, then, because I answered your question in the very post of mine you quoted.
Directly or indirectly, the Offense has LITERALLY NOTHING AT ALL to do with the Defense's play. If the Offense fumbles the ball at the 1 yard line, I fully expect the Defense to keep the opponent out of the end zone. That's their job.
It's insane to blame the problems of one side of the ball on any other side. The Defense is to blame for not stopping UCLA. The Offense is to blame for failing to score after hitting 21 points.
Knapp, I know this has been broached before, but basically my two cents...
I agree with you wholeheartedly. The defense cannot point their finger at the offense for their porblems or vice versa. The defense has to stop people. And the offense has to score points.
BUT...
I think that the folks that believe there is more blame for the offense than the defense and therefore let that spillover into blaming the offense for everything do so because more is expected of the offense. We ALL knew going into this season that the O was going to have to carry the extremely young D. We're breaking in new players at basically 8 of 11 spots on the defense this year, and growing pains were totally expected with that level of inexperience. Meanwhile, the O wields the best corps of WR's NU has ever had, a legitimate 3 deep at RB, SUPPOSEDLY the best OL we've had during Bo's tenure (color me skeptical), and to top it off, a 4 year record holding QB running the show.
I think it's obviously to any of us by now that Bo's teams are wildly inconsistent. They seem to handle adversity VERY poorly (although, the cardiac combeacks last season could form an argument against this)-- in that when things start to go wrong, they compound and continue to get worse and worse until we've made the game unwinnable. This is a trend we've seen far to often and it distrubs the hell out of me. I absolutely abhor the fact that in the season we finally have permanant captains and a ton of important contributing seniors, NO ONE is shown rallying the troops or getting fired up on the sideline. Who is going to hold anyone accountable?! The time to do it is during the game to get the ship righted and try to win, not afterwards with a sheepish look on your face because you just peed another game down your leg... But I digress...
The handling of adversity... the snowballing of problems once they begin... and the wild inconsistency and underacheivement of this team even within games (i.e., playing lights out one series and crappiing the bed the next) indicates the psychological problem within the team and coaches by extension that people have pointed to in the past. They just do not seem to be able to respond well to the other team scoring once or twice and instead seem to retreat into a shell. The same goes for coaches. One part of me feels extremely bad for the players... I'm finally of the belief that a huge part of the blame for the offense yesterday should go to Beck. In the past I've tended to think it was just on the players, but these UCLA games (between what we saw yesterday and that damn zone read in the endzone last year) have done Beck in for me. I'm officially off his bandwagon, and he's starting to p*ss me off.
I finally saw a great explanation of it yesterday: The best coaches have their base system or scheme in place, and run it every game. They will tweak it to take advantage of what they think they can exploit on the other team. Beck seems to abandon any type of base offense so to speak and instead exclusively devise and run a gameplan for each new opponent each week. We do have the zone read and the toss sweep which we see every week. But, instead of deciding what we do WELL and DOING IT, Beck seems to think it is better to try to force what we may NOT DO AS WELL simply because he's seen something on tape that leads him to believe the opposing defense is weak against it. Well, we often fail to execute those particular plays (god... I sound like Bo) because we don't normally run them, lose yards or gain minimal ones, and it blows up in our face.
Basically, it boils down to Beck trying to get cute and outscheme the other team rather than doing what we do well. And it has me as fed up as all the rest of you.
Sorry, I tried not to ramble. The point is, they blame the offense because WAY more was expected of them. And it isn't even entirely the offenses fault. A majority of the blame should go to Tim Beck. But the defense bears blame too. Moreover, I believe a huge part of the blowout losses is a pervasive psychological tendency to give up and inability to regain focus and execute well when things start to go wrong, which obviously leads to snowballing and games getting out of hand.
I will give it the rest of the season. There is always hope. But Beck is really blowing games with his damn play calling, and if the psychological problem remains and we don't win the B1G this year, I don't know that it will ever get better under Bo (with this staff) and it may be time to change things up.