Blind QB poll

[Cdog923]

Just looking at some overall QB stats from this year; in a blind poll, with everything else equal, who are you taking?  No Googling!

 

QB 1: 152/229, 66%, 1844 yds, 19 TDs, 4 INTs, 65 yds rushing, 1 TD, 3 Fumbles 79.5 QBR.

 

QB 2: 182/272, 67%, 2212 yds, 15 TDs, 7 INTS, 535 yds rushing, 7 TDs, 10 Fumbles 68.4 QBR

 

QB 3: 83/121, 68%, 1350 yds, 13 TDs, 2 INTs, 252 yrds rush, 2 TDs, 2 Fumbles 85.0 QBR

[Mavric]

It would be pretty hard to pass up QB3 because of the better YPA and fewer INTs.

 

But give me QB2 with the better rushing numbers to go with the passing.

[junior4949]

I went with QB3 because of the best INT to TD ratio.  Plus, he can run well enough to keep the defense honest.  The one thing missing that I would liked to have seen was how many carries each QB had to get those rushing yards. 

[Huskerzoo]

QBR is pretty all-encompassing. I'm going with #3

[Ulty]

If these are blind QBs as the title says, all of these stats are pretty impressive!

[commando]

QB2....over 2700 total yards and 22 total TDS.   am a bit concerned about 7 ints though

[Ulty]

I wonder about the yards per carry average to go along with the rushing numbers. QB3 is more efficient, but seems to be utilized much less. Is that QB capable of maintaining the same efficiency if he is needed to throw more often or carry an entire team on his back? 

 

QB2 has better overall production, but the question is about the turnovers.

 

I supppose if QB2 is a freshman quarterback who threw a bunch of picks early but cleaned up the turnovers as the season went on, I would like that. 

[Nebfanatic]

Can we get a number of fumbles too? Looking at total TDs vs total turnovers. No fumbles factored in QB 2 has a slight edge over QB 3. QB 3 has incredible efficiency but QB 2 is just putting up numbers with good efficiency to boot. QB 1 is right there and may be somes pick because he gives you a little of both.

 

Edit: without googling I already know who QB 2 is and I know he gets knocked a bit when you factor in the fumbles. He will clean that up though in time  really excited about the future.

[Cdog923]

7 minutes ago, Nebfanatic said:

Can we get a number of fumbles too? Looking at total TDs vs total turnovers. No fumbles factored in QB 2 has a slight edge over QB 3. QB 3 has incredible efficiency but QB 2 is just putting up numbers with good efficiency to boot. QB 1 is right there and may be somes pick because he gives you a little of both.

 

I'm efforting to find fumbles, but most teams just list them as a team stat, rather than an individual stat. 

[broganreynik]

I voted QB3, but in retrospect, they seem pretty Tyrod Taylor-like. As a Browns fan, that disturbs me.

 

I’m switching to QB1. I’d like to know how many times each QB was sacked (to account for rushing yards), QB hurries, and how many fumbles; but as it stands, the turnovers concern me the most.

[Nebfanatic]

4 minutes ago, Cdog923 said:

 

I'm efforting to find fumbles, but most teams just list them as a team stat, rather than an individual stat. 

Yea its not easy to find as I remember looking for them as well. I believe QB 2 has 5, QB 3 has 2 and I have no clue who QB 1 is.

 

Edit: try the stats on cbs sports

[swmohusker]

I chose 2.  A lot of variables that would effect the decision.  What year are they, what offense they run, what type of schedule they play, etc.....

[StPaulHusker]

I chose QB2 due to the number of TD's

[Nebfanatic]

Took the fun out of it

[Cdog923]

I'll update the main post, but QB 1 has 3, QB 2 has 10 and QB 3 has 2. 

1 minute ago, Nebfanatic said:

QB 4: 175/247, 71%, 3038 yds, 32 TDs, 5 INTs, 640 yds rushing, 7 rush TDs, 1 fumble, (can't find the QBR you are using)

 

ESPN.